A curated collection of finds — from handcrafted home goods to one-of-a-kind gifts — chosen with care and sold with a smile, just off Dolson Ave.
Your Treasure Shop started with a simple idea: that shopping locally shouldn't mean choosing between quality and character. In a town as grounded and warm as Middletown, we saw a space for something different — a place where every item has a story and every visitor feels like a regular.
We travel, we hand-select, and we bring back finds that we genuinely believe in. Nothing on our shelves is there by accident. If it doesn't spark something, it doesn't stay.
Our shelves rotate constantly — new arrivals, seasonal picks, and the occasional happy discovery that changes everything.
Candles, ceramics, textiles — pieces that turn a house into a home, one thoughtful detail at a time.
For the person who has everything — or the person you barely know and want to surprise. We make it easy.
Supporting makers close to home. Every purchase here carries the fingerprints of someone who made it with care.
Shopping should feel like a conversation, not a transaction. Every shelf in our shop is arranged to invite you to slow down, look closer, and discover something you didn't know you were looking for.
That's the treasure part. It's not just what you find — it's the moment you find it.
Every item earns its place. No filler, no fast-fashion fatigue — just goods we'd put in our own homes.
We partner with makers who value craft over volume, and quality over quantity.
We're your neighbors. Your satisfaction and our shared community matter more than any sale.
52 Dolson Ave
Middletown, NY 10940-6424
Monday – Saturday: 10am – 6pm
Sunday: 11am – 5pm
Free street parking available directly outside the shop.
Every visit is different. Every shelf holds something new. Come in — we'll save you a spot.
